Bay Shore Inn

Bay Shore, United States View on map
Editor's Pick

"Rooms at this motel include both smoking and non-smoking options, with warm interiors and hot water. It remains a budget-friendly choice for short stays. Made for road-trippers, and not for anyone expecting pristine maintenance."

from US$ 145 US$ 130 per night
Save 10%
Check-in
22 Nov 2026
Check-out
23 Nov 2026
Guests
2 guests

Adults:

2

Children:

0
  • Free cancellation
    on many rooms
  • No booking fees
    Pay at the hotel
  • Secure booking
    Your data is safe
  • Best price guarantee
    Found a better price?

Why guests choose Bay Shore Inn

  • Private Sand Beach
    Sturgeon Bay shoreline
  • Heated Pools
    Indoor & outdoor
  • Kayaks & Paddleboards
    Complimentary seasonal
  • Sports Court
    Pickleball & basketball
  • EV Charging
    On-site station
  • Fish Boil History
    70-year tradition

Overview

Providing 13 rooms, Bay Shore Inn is approximately 10 minutes' drive from Sagtikos Manor.

The center of Bay Shore can be reached within a 30-minute walk, and natural attractions like Gardiner County Park are 1.5 miles away. This 2-star hotel is around 15 minutes by car from Belmont Lake State Park in Bay Shore. Guests will also appreciate the vicinity to Wohseepee Park, located merely 0.7 miles away. The Inn Bay Shore is situated right near Shipwreck Cove Spray Park, while Suffolk County bus station lies only 10 minutes' walk away.

The rooms feature climate control, along with a flat-screen TV with satellite channels for guests' utmost comfort. Guests can make use of bath sheets and towels in the bathrooms equipped with a separate toilet and a shower.

The Bright Bay Deli & Caterers is 0.2 miles from the Inn.

  • Check-in
    from 13:00 until 23:59
  • Check-out
    until 11:00
  • Hotel class
    2 stars
Bay Shore Inn
Our tips

Should you book Bay Shore Inn?

Perfect if you
  • Need free on-site parking - the hotel offers a car park directly at the property.
  • Want a motel with spa therapy and a prime touristic area available for guests.
Maybe skip if you
  • Expect an on-site restaurant for dinner - the only nearby dining is Bright Bay Deli & Caterers, a 5-minute walk away.
Best for
  • A location near Sagtikos Manor, 1.8 miles from the hotel

Facilities of Bay Shore Inn

Room Amenities
  • Free toiletries
  • Flat-screen TV
  • AM/FM alarm clock
  • Carpeted floor

Policies

Bay Shore Inn applies these conditions to all bookings.
Check-in / Check-out
Check-in
from 13:00 until 23:59
Check-out
until 11:00
Important info
  • Children and extra beds
  • There are no cribs provided in a room.

Thank you for your feedback

Thank you for subscribing

Close
Check-in
22 Nov 2026
Check-out
23 Nov 2026
Guests
2 guests

Adults:

2

Children:

0
Select the dates
to see the actual offers